Spencer reveals that an ex-girlfriend of his works as a makeup artist for TV and movies in LA, and he convinces her to help him and the i Carly gang—Carly, Sam and Freddie are given heavy prosthetic makeup while Gibby's given a hat, sunglasses and a fake mole. Gibby: [holds up a radish] Well I know about 'em now, don't I? With the exception of one guy recognizing Gibby (who Gibby is forced to knock unconscious so he doesn't tell his friends about him and the i Carly trio being at the party), they're able to sneak into the party and look for Steven without being recognized. Sikowitz, Beck, Jade, and Spencer spend the time in Kenan Thompson's jacuzzi.
[class starts laughing uproariously] Sam: Yeah, like you got a lot of room to call other people socially deprived weirdos. Howard: Do you want to get kicked out of this class?!
[Everyone is silent for a few seconds] So, moving on....
After Carly sees Steven giving Tori the exact same charm bracelet he gave her and also kissing, she discusses her course of action with Sam and Freddie when Tori comes in. Freddie: [hushed tone] I don't [motioning quotation marks] "hate her"! Benson, not that we don't all want you to leave, but why are you here? Freddie: [turns to her] Like your family is not full of freaks and mutants. Sam: How come you've never heard about the 100-day kiss thing?
After telling her about Steven dating both of them, they team up to take revenge on him. Marissa: Well, I don't see how a boy can make a girl that happy.
With Kenan Thompson's help, they reveal Steven to be a cheater and a liar live on i Carly. Sam: Sure, 'cause you haven't had a date since Seinfield got cancelled.